accessibility-icon
share-icon

VIDEO

Photo: Shutterstock

NYC Mayor Mamdani Stumbles Over Oct. 7 Anniversary Question

Asaf Nissan

By: Rivka Sorek

Editor: Asaf Nissan

12:30

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani had an awkward moment at a New York Times conference when Andrew Ross Sorkin asked why he chose the anniversary of October 7 to attack Israel. Mamdani struggled to answer but did not retract his accusations, claiming Israel uses the massacre as “justification for everything that came after.”


New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani found himself in an awkward moment yesterday at a New York Times conference after being asked why he chose to attack Israel on the anniversary of the October 7 massacre. He struggled to answer but didn’t back down from his accusations against Israel, claiming the massacre serves as “a justification for all that followed it.”

maximize-image
images-count1+
October 7 massacre | Photo: Flash 90

During an interview with journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin, Mamdani was asked to explain a statement he released marking three years since the October 7 massacre, in which he devoted less than a quarter of his remarks to remembering the victims and most of his comments to events in Gaza. In that statement, he accused Israel: “The suffering did not begin on that day, nor did it end there. It continues through the devastating and ongoing genocide being carried out by the Israeli government in Gaza.”

Sorkin noted that the statement drew sharp criticism from Jewish leaders, who argued the mayor’s words undermined the sense of security for New York Jews. He asked Mamdani whether, given the rise in hate crimes against Jews in the city, he felt a special responsibility in choosing his words. But Mamdani rejected the criticism and claimed the interviewer’s description “doesn’t reflect everything that happened that day.”

To illustrate his commitment to the Jewish community, the mayor mentioned that he attended a memorial ceremony for the massacre victims, where he was heckled by anti-Israel protesters. Mamdani explained that for him, there’s no contradiction between mourning the murdered in Israel and criticizing Israel: “My political approach is based on the belief that there must be room to mourn everyone,” adding that he’s proud to lead the city with the largest Jewish community in the United States.

But the word salad didn’t satisfy Sorkin, who pressed the mayor and wondered whether it wouldn’t have been appropriate to dedicate October 7 to condemning the Hamas massacre, and wait until the next day to condemn Israel. The question drew reactions from the audience, and according to the New York Post, Mamdani turned red and struggled to respond fluently.

מחבלים מעזה ליד טנק בגבול עזה ב-7 באוקטובר, ארכיון |
maximize-image
images-count1+
Photo: Flash 90

Once again, the mayor didn’t back down from his accusations, claiming Israel uses the massacre to justify its actions since the war began: “When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given, no matter what day that it’s asked about, will be the relationship to Oct. 7.”