accessibility-icon
share-icon

VIDEO

Photo: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90
Ronen Itzik

2 minutes ago


A Binational Government Is a Danger to Israel

As Gadi Eisenkot explores a government backed by Arab parties, a fundamental question arises: on what national basis would such a government stand? Civil partnership is legitimate, but making Israel’s Jewish identity a bargaining chip in coalition talks is not.


It’s stunning to see that in the eyes of a non-fringe political group in Israel, a binational government is legitimate. This proves that, in their view, the state was established to allow one political configuration or another to come to power, whatever it may be. This is important because the founders intended to establish a Jewish state to ensure the Jewish people’s right to self-determination in their homeland. Therefore, Gadi Eisenkot’s political strategy demands a fundamental and highly significant question: On what national basis does he intend to establish a government here, and what commitments will enable its formation?

maximize-image
images-count2+
Photo: Yonatan Sindel, Flash90

The danger isn’t that Arab Knesset members are partners in public decisions. Equal citizenship includes the right to vote, be elected, and have influence. The danger begins when the price of forming a government is dependence on elements seeking to challenge Israel’s character as the nation-state of the Jewish people, or to subordinate its policy to advancing a national goal that contradicts its purpose.

This is the difference between civic partnership and partnership in changing the state’s identity. Promoting infrastructure, fighting crime, improving education, and reducing gaps are shared Israeli interests. In contrast, abandoning Jewish self-definition is not just another budget item in coalition negotiations. It touches on the very reason the state whose leadership they’re competing for was established.

A government can be legally legitimate from a parliamentary standpoint and still cause major upheaval, which is why a Knesset majority is a condition for forming a government. Still, it doesn’t answer every question about its path. The public must know not only how many fingers will support it, but what the agreements that will bind them together mean, and what will happen when a fateful security or political decision is required.

maximize-image
images-count2+
Photo: Yonatan Sindel, Flash90

When a government depends on partners who don’t accept the Jewish people’s right to national sovereignty, it’s clear that the dispute over the state’s identity will enter into its decision-making mechanism. In such a situation, every coalition crisis could become a lever of pressure on issues that must not be decided out of governing ambition; therefore, the discussion cannot be limited to a slogan that any political combination is justified in using to replace a government. Changing government is an important democratic option—but it’s less important than the purpose for which we established a Jewish nation-state.

The matter becomes more serious when what’s at stake is a coalition supported by votes of those calling for and promoting the establishment of a ‘Palestinian’ state. The practical meaning of this is support for eliminating Israel as a nation-state, and a mortal blow to Jewish sovereignty. Such a coalition would de facto create a surrender of Israel’s national uniqueness and turn it into a binational framework, and here arises a fundamental, sharp, and dangerous problem. In such a framework, ‘Palestinian’ self-definition receives expression in its own state, while Jewish self-definition loses the state framework meant to ensure it. From this stems the fear of a reality in which ‘Palestinian’ nationalism gains sovereign status in part of the land and equal national status within Israel itself.

maximize-image
images-count2+
Mansour Abbas with terror-supporting Sheikh Raed Salah | photo: screenshot

No one intended to use defense of the Jewish state to deny the rights of its Arab citizens. Civic equality is not a threat to Zionism, and a state secure in its identity should guarantee every citizen security, dignity, and opportunity. The dividing line is not between Jews and Arabs, but between partnership that accepts the state’s framework and a demand to replace its national purpose.

It’s worth understanding this danger, and it’s not political demagoguery. The concept that an equal-rights minority lives in a nation-state is a binding reality. Still, it absolutely cannot come at the expense of the exclusive national right that Jews have in Israel. Regarding nation and identity, there cannot be equality—our state’s nation is Jewish. This is its purpose, this is its uniqueness, and for this, and only for this, it was established. Therefore, a binational government is bad and dangerous, and it would constitute a system that de facto undermines the creation of a distorted decision-making mechanism in the context of the nation-state.

While there’s no reason and it’s also wrong to prevent Arabs from having rights including parliamentary ones, their national rights and their desire to bring them to expression in the sovereign framework—must not be allowed. You can be an Israeli Arab, but you cannot apply your nationalism to the public sphere in Israel—you’re welcome to do that in Damascus, Amman, Cairo, Abu Dhabi, and Tripoli. And whoever lends a hand to such a change from liberal motives will crush the nation-state principle and bring us all to a point of no return.


Asaf Nissan